Post After Post-Mortem by E.C.R. Lorac (1936) 4/5 stars
In this volume of Lorac's long-running series featuring Inspector Robert Macdonald, a young woman's suicide garners suspicion after her last letter is received. Scores of lies were told at the inquest to protect her memory, the uncovering of which leads to many clues, and red herrings. As Macdonald investigates her life, he discovers a myriad of motives among her friends and family.
This is an intelligent, well-written and interesting mystery. It was complex but not convoluted, twisty enough to keep me guessing, and held my attention throughout. The solution and motive were unanticipated, and not fully credible, but the book is certainly worth reading.
The Black Wings by Moray Dalton (1927) 5/5 stars
This is a complicated story, and not easy to summarize without spoiling the plot. It's made up of murder, blackmail, family secrets, abduction, light romance, police procedure, and courtroom drama, with a nod to the classic Jane Eyre.
This book is advertised as "A Golden Age Mystery", but that is not quite accurate. Though there is a mystery, this is actually a crime novel of suspense and adventure, with elements that are not at all typical of a Golden Age Mystery. It is well-written, intelligent, and, while over-the-top at times, absolutely absorbing all the way up to the stunning conclusion.
The Tragedy at Freyne by Anthony Gilbert (1927) 4/5 stars
An artist, Sir Simon Chandos, is found dead in his study, apparently by his own hand, but a discrepancy reveals that it was actually murder. His friend, who has loved Chandos' wife for years, is the obvious suspect and is quickly arrested. A confession from a different party follows, and it appears that the crime is solved, but another friend is not satisfied and proceeds to investigate on his own.
This mystery is clever, interesting, and well-written. It is narrated in the first person by a Watson of sorts whose believable voice adds greatly to the book. The solution was unexpected, and may not have been solvable from the information given, but overall this is a satisfying read.
Side Note:
Interestingly enough, all three of these authors are women using pen names, and I was unable to find a photo any one of them!
comments are temporarily disabled
